Skip to Content

We Are All Paris

Found in: Lily's Blackboard

I am just back from my first meeting as a new regional vice president of Education International,  an organization with the powerful solidarity of almost 400 educational unions and associations in 171 countries that represents more than 32 million educators from preschool to graduate school.  They hold their meetings at their headquarters this week in Brussels.

No one knew what would be happening in Paris and in Brussels months ago when we all made our arrangements to be there. We were to receive an important report about refugee children and how camps and receiving countries were serving (or not) the education needs of these vulnerable students, but the agenda was not centered on terrorists and security alerts. The world can change in an hour.

I was taken back to September 11, 2001 when our world changed.  I was teaching at the children’s shelter in Salt Lake City, The Christmas Box House.  I watched the twin towers fall while fixing breakfast.  Shell-shocked, I got to the shelter and found the children were huddled around the big screen TV watching the horror repeated over and over and over again.

I brought my students – aged 5 to 12 – to the one-room classroom down the hall and had no idea what I was supposed to say to them.  Nothing in my teacher training prepared me to explain to little children the darkest side of humanity and the reality of real-time mass murder of innocent bystanders who could have been any one of them.

I fumbled and stumbled my way through it.  And after all this time and countless tragedies, it is a fresh shock each time, and each time we need to reminded what we can do.  Which is why I was so grateful to see an email from Ron Benner, an activist with the Connecticut affiliate of the National Association of School Psychologists.   There are educators amongst us who are specialists in child psychology, and they have studied how to guide students through these terrible events.

Not that terrible events are new.  The world has a history of death and cruelty.  We study it in school.  But when it is before us; when it is not some dark, medieval time, or storm troopers in black and white documentaries, but something organized yesterday through tweets and Facebook pages, we are impacted in a profoundly different way.  It makes us afraid.  We see that this could happen anywhere.  To anyone.  To us.  But the first step is not to fear, but to grieve, because the loss is to our human family.

They are us.  They are ours.  We are Oklahoma City and Columbine, Sandy Hook and Charleston. We are New York City.  We are Paris.  We are a drowned toddler fleeing with his mother from the brutality of a civil war.  We are connected to these images as part of us, and ignoring the grief and fear can cause great psychological harm to anyone, but especially to children.  But there are steps we can take.  It isn’t magic, and it won’t make the horror disappear.  It’s human.  It’s truth.  It’s expressing what’s inside.  It’s channeling a way to reach in and reach out.

I thank the National Association of School Psychologists for their powerful advice and pass it on to parents and educators and all who are called on to serve children. All Adults Should:

  1. Model calm and control. Children take their emotional cues from the significant adults in their lives. Avoid appearing anxious or frightened.
  2. Reassure children they are safe and (if true) so are the important adults and other loved ones in their lives. Depending on the situation, point out factors that help ensure their immediate safety and that of their community.
  3. Remind them trustworthy people are in charge. Explain that emergency workers, police, firefighters, doctors, and the government are helping people who are hurt and are working to ensure that no further tragedies like this occur.
  4. Let children know it is okay to feel upset. Explain all feelings are okay when a tragedy like this occurs. Let children talk about their feelings and help put them into perspective. Even anger is okay, but children may need help and patience from adults to assist them in expressing these feelings appropriately.
  5. Tell children the truth. Don't try to pretend the event has not occurred or that it is not serious. Children are smart. They will be more worried if they think you are too afraid to tell them what is happening. At the same time it will be important to tell children that while the threat of terrorism is real, the chances they will be personally affected is low
  6. Stick to the facts. Don't embellish or speculate about what has happened, or where another attack might occur. Don't dwell on the scale or scope of the tragedy, particularly with young children.
  7. Be careful not to stereotype people or countries that might be associated with the violence. Children can easily generalize negative statements and develop prejudice. Talk about tolerance and justice versus vengeanceStop any bullying or teasing immediately.
  8. Keep your explanations developmentally appropriateEarly elementary school children need brief, simple information that should be balanced with reassurances that the daily structures of their lives will not change. Upper elementary and early middle school children will be more vocal in asking questions about whether they truly are safe. They may need assistance separating reality from fantasy. Upper middle school and high school students will have strong and varying opinions about the causes of violence and threats to safety in schools and society. They will share concrete suggestions about how to make school safer and how to prevent tragedies in society. They will be more committed to doing something to help the victims and affected community. For all children, encourage them to verbalize their thoughts and feelings. Be a good listener!
  9. Maintain a "normal" routine. To the extent possible stick to normal classroom or family routines but don't be inflexible. Children may have a hard time concentrating on schoolwork or falling asleep at night.
  10. Monitor or restrict exposure to scenes of the event as well as the aftermath. In particular, monitor exposure to social media. For older children, caution against accessing news coverage from only one source.
  11. Observe children's emotional state. Depending on their age, children may not express their concerns verbally. Changes in behavior, appetite, and sleep patterns can also indicate a child's level of grief, anxiety or discomfort. Children will express their emotions differently. There is no right or wrong way to feel or express fear or grief.
  12. Be aware of children at greater risk. Children who have a connection to this particular event, have had a past traumatic experience or personal loss, suffer from depression or other mental illness, or with special needs may be at greater risk for severe reactions than others. Be particularly observant for those who may be at risk of suicide. Seek the help of a mental health professional if you are at all concerned.
  13. Provide an outlet for students' desire to help. Consider making get well cards or sending letters to the families and survivors of the tragedy, or writing thank you letters to doctors, nurses, and other health care professionals as well as emergency rescue workers, firefighters and police.
  14. Keep lines of communication open between home and school. Schools are a good place for children to experience a sense of normalcy. Being with their friends and teachers is helpful. Schools should inform families about available resources, such as talking points or counseling, and plans for information sharing and discussions with students. Parents should let their child's teacher or school mental health professional know if they have concerns or feel their child may need extra support.
  15. Monitor your own stress level. Don't ignore your own feelings of anxiety, grief, and anger. Talking to friends, family members, religious leaders, and mental health counselors can help. It is okay to let your children know you are sad, but that you believe things will get better. You will be better able to support your children if you can express your own emotions in a productive manner. Get appropriate sleep, nutrition, and exercise.

Again, my thanks to our colleagues at the National Association of School Psychologists for their wisdom and professionalism.  The message they send us to focus on our common humanity.  To allow students to express their human feelings of fear and confusion.  To allow them to hear our own confusion and our own sadness.  To help them find ways of comforting the victims, the survivors and even themselves.